AI can produce a convincing answer to almost anything I ask my students. It can produce a second, a more confident third, and a presentation making all three look inevitable.
But what some students miss is that they still have to decide what they think.
A renown Designer I follow, Tobias van Schneider, recently wrote about software becoming easier to build, and the importance of “taste, philosophy, and conviction.” I thought immediately of my students. When everyone can produce plausible work, what makes a contribution unmistakably yours?
I want them to leave with an eye for what matters, principles they can explain, and opinions they have worked hard enough to defend. Not just another framework neatly reproduced on a slide.
Business schools make that harder than we admit. We ask for independent thinking, then prescribe the method, the route and sometimes even the acceptable answer. I have done it myself, writing assignments so meticulously structured that the meaningful decisions disappeared. Years of faculty procedures had taught me that habit rather well.
But things have changed.
In my recent export marketing course in Nice, I assigned each team a premium beverage category and drinking occasion. They chose their starting country, export market, customer, positioning, price and distribution. My welcome email probably made it sound considerably easier than it turned out to be.
Every attractive decision sent a bill elsewhere. A premium bottle needed someone willing to pay for it. Prices had to survive taxes and distributor margins. Distribution needed an actual partner. I challenged assumptions, helped them through the mess and watched their thinking develop.
By the time they defended their strategies before me and an industry professional, the decisions belonged to them. Our conversations went much deeper than they anticipated. I could see it on their faces: pride, nervousness, and sometimes the uncomfortable recognition that a beautiful idea still had a rather large hole in it.
This is why I love teaching.
Freedom does not mean abandoning standards. Quite the opposite. Give students a real problem, evidence and constraints. Then give them authority over the decisions. Let them surprise us, defend their reasoning and revise a conclusion when the evidence demands it. Fundamentally, a student who reaches a defensible conclusion I disagree with should still be able to earn an excellent grade.
Opinions are abundant - the internet has taken care of that. An opinion worth listening to demands knowledge, humility, resilience and someone willing to ask the awkward question. That’s my role.
I care deeply about what my students bring to work. I hope they leave not merely knowing what to do when instructed, but prepared to choose a direction when nobody hands them one.


